The Court of Appeal has upheld a ruling that quashed the 2016 transfer of a Southern Province teacher, finding that he was moved without a proper inquiry or a chance to be heard.
The judgment was delivered on 17 November. It concerned the transfer of Halwitigala Ihala Gamage Sunil from Janadhipathi Balika Vidyalaya in Galle to Kapuhenpola Nandimithra Maha Vidyalaya.
According to court documents, the teacher had served in the Southern Province since 1992. In March 2016 he complained to the school principal about the alleged consumption of alcohol by a minor staff member on school premises.
He later took part in a protest outside the school and made statements to the media as Secretary of the Southern Provincial Branch of the Lanka Teachers Association. Education authorities issued him a severe warning on 27 July 2016. He challenged the allegations and asked for the warning to be withdrawn. He was then transferred to another school with immediate effect.
The teacher took the matter to the Provincial High Court in Galle, which ruled in his favour on 31 May 2019. That court found the transfer had been made without a proper disciplinary inquiry or a reasonable opportunity to respond. It also questioned whether powers had been validly delegated under the Provincial Councils Act.
Background
Southern Provincial authorities appealed against the High Court judgment. In its latest ruling, the Court of Appeal found that the Governor of the Southern Province had validly delegated powers to the Provincial Public Service Commission under Section 32 of the Provincial Councils Act.
The Court therefore set aside the High Court’s finding on the delegation of powers, and partially allowed the appeal on that point.
However, it noted that the authorities had not challenged the High Court’s separate finding that the teacher was denied a proper inquiry and a fair hearing. The Court held that this procedural unfairness was enough to invalidate the transfer, whatever the position on delegation.
It upheld the cancellation of the transfer and the related orders made by the High Court. It also declined to interfere with the Rs. 75,000 in costs the High Court had awarded.
The case took about 10 years from the transfer in 2016 to the Court of Appeal judgment in 2026, with the High Court ruling coming in between in 2019.
What it means
The judgment confirms that a public officer facing a transfer that follows allegations against them is entitled to a proper inquiry and a chance to answer those allegations before the transfer is carried out.
For teachers and other provincial public servants, the ruling shows that a transfer can be set aside on grounds of procedural unfairness alone, even when the authority that ordered it acted within its delegated powers. The ruling turned on the lack of a fair hearing, not on who made the order.
Education authorities in the provinces may need to ensure that a disciplinary inquiry is held, and that the officer concerned is heard, before ordering a transfer that arises from allegations of misconduct.