The Court of Appeal has dismissed a writ application by Hingurana Distilleries (Pvt) Ltd and its Managing Director seeking the refund of Rs. 270 million paid to Sri Lanka Customs, and ordered the petitioners to pay Rs. 1 million in State costs.
The judgment was delivered on Wednesday by a two-judge bench of Justice B. Sasi Mahendran and Justice Adithya Patabendige. Justice Patabendige agreed with the judgment written by Justice Sasi Mahendran.
The petitioners, the company and its Managing Director, V.A.D.N.P. Perera, had asked the court to overturn a Customs decision and order the refund of the sum the company said it had paid as forfeitures.
The court found that the petitioners had failed to show that the Customs decision was unlawful, unreasonable or affected by an error of law that would justify judicial intervention.
It also observed that the individuals directly affected by the original Customs decision had not been made parties to the application, and that the Managing Director had not disclosed material facts in his affidavit, including his earlier admission of responsibility and his undertaking not to challenge the Customs order.
Background
The dispute dates back to 2015, when Sri Lanka Customs investigated allegations that the distillery had used about 51,860 litres of ethyl alcohol that was allegedly imported without payment of Customs duties. Following an inquiry, Customs imposed financial forfeitures on the company, its Managing Director and its employees in April 2015.
During that inquiry, two employees said they had bought alcohol privately from a third-party supplier and used it in liquor production for personal financial gain, according to the facts before the court. The petitioners argued that these activities took place without the knowledge or involvement of the company’s management.
The Court of Appeal noted that the Managing Director had accepted responsibility during the Customs inquiry, citing inadequate supervision and internal controls. He had also stated at the time that he did not intend to challenge the Customs decision in another forum.
A writ application asks the Court of Appeal to review whether a public authority acted within the law. It does not ask the court to re-hear the facts, which is why the court examined whether the Customs decision was unlawful, unreasonable or based on a legal error rather than whether the original findings were right on the evidence.
What it means
For the company, the ruling means the Rs. 270 million it sought to recover stays with the State, and it must also meet the Rs. 1 million in costs. The decision leaves the 2015 Customs forfeitures in place.
More broadly, the judgment shows how the court treats challenges to Customs decisions when a party has earlier accepted responsibility and undertaken not to dispute the outcome. Businesses that deal with Customs inquiries can read it as a reminder that statements made during such an inquiry may be relied on later if the matter reaches court.